Should immigrants be required to disavow Sharia law? (Tancredo, Jim Harper/Cato)
Rep. Tom Tancredo has introduced H.R. 6975 (link), a very short bill that would amend the Immigration and Nationality Act to say:
(G) SHARIA LAW SYSTEM- Any alien who fails to attest, in accordance with procedures specified by the Secretary of Homeland Security, that the alien will not advocate installing a Sharia law system in the United States is inadmissible.
I'm mostly all for it, and for a lot of similar things. While we certainly want to avoid requiring loyalty oaths of those who are already citizens, there's no reason we should admit those who don't buy in to our fundamental concepts, whether Constitutional or, in the case of Aztlan, our terroritorial claims.
Needless to say, the usual suspects won't like it, and one of those is Jim Harper from the Cato Institute, a supposed libertarian group with some interesting funders and which has put forth some odiously anti- and un-American ideas. Says Harper (cato-at-liberty.org/2008/09/20/fear-of-sharia-oh-please):
But more importantly, a law like this communicates precisely the wrong thing to new immigrants and the world at large. It tells the world that we’re a weak, fearful country, and that we believe Sharia law is possible in the United States. It tells the world that we’ve come off our traditional moorings and that we no longer believe in free speech and tolerance of all opinions, no matter how wrong.
Unfortunately, we have to a certain extent come off our "traditional moorings", both because of those who put money before fundamental American concepts (see Cato) and because of those on the far-left who've been mainstreamed (see the ACLU, etc.) And, of course, Sharia law barely failed in Canada but is apparently now part of England's laws.
Why take the risk just to prove something?
However, Harper is willing to make a guarantee:
There is no possibility — none — that Sharia law will be established in the United States. Not by any government body at any level.
Of course, his guarantee means nothing; if he's wrong would anyone notice? If anyone did, he'd probably just say he was wrong or just move somewhere else. It's better to be safe than sorry, and a guarantee from Harper is worthless.
Comments
Mary (not verified)
Mon, 09/22/2008 - 23:53
Permalink
HS 15697 maryellenburke2005@comcast.net 2008-09-23T01:53:52-05:0
Heck NO...let's become like Britain...everyone get yourselves a knife...amke it a big one...and be sure to avoid people carrying large book bags on the subway......AH, thanks Jorge Farah Bush for such fine diversity... Hope you're happy with your new world order and don't forget..Your grandchildren will CURSE you til the day they die!
Muslims Against... (not verified)
Tue, 09/23/2008 - 04:44
Permalink
HS 15698 mash1@reformislam.org 2008-09-23T06:44:47-05:00
MUSLIMS AGAINST SHARIA PRAISE CONGRESSMAN TANCREDO\'S INITIATIVE. WE ADVOCATED SIMILAR MEASURES IN THE PAST AND FULLY SUPPORT "GIHAD PREVENTION ACT" "Any person from a country where a substantial part of the population is pro-Sharia should not be allowed in the West, not only as an immigrant, but even as a visitor with a few exceptions, i.e., political asylum or as a diplomat etc. ... Every legal immigrant should be allowed to stay only if he/she did not display desire to establish a Sharia state in a host country. Any naturalized citizen who displays a desire to establish a Sharia state in a host country should have his/her citizenship revoked and promptly deported. I think the latter two groups is where the real danger lies." Linda Ahmed, FrontPage Magazine, July 24, 2008 "Anyone who proclaims Islamic extremist views should be tried for sedition, since we are at war with radical Islam, or at the very least, promptly deported." Khalim Massoud, FrontPage Magazine, September 9, 2008 http://muslimsagainstsharia.blogspot.com/2008/09/tancredo-proposes-anti-sharia-measure.html [1]
Links:
------
[1] muslimsagainstsharia.blogspot.com/2008/09/tancredo-proposes-anti-sharia-measure.html
Nancys (not verified)
Wed, 09/24/2008 - 10:19
Permalink
HS 15699 nsivill@yahoo.com 2008-09-24T12:19:34-05:00
Specifics of the bill-- http://hdm9305.wordpress.com/2008/09/23/tom-tancredo-saves-america-from-the-constitution-again/