Take action now: Take the Stop Amnesty Challenge.

It's up to you to block Obama's amnesty.
 

Is immigration reform an amnesty? (Yes)

"Amnesty" is a bad word, so many supporters of comprehensive immigration reform have played oftentimes complicated word games to pretend that "reform" is not amnesty. Those who do that are simply trying to deceive. While we could argue all day long about whether what they support fits the dictionary definition of "amnesty", and arguing over terms may be something that those supporters intentionally try to do, what really matters is how "reform" will be perceived.

And, millions upon millions of people around the world will perceive "reform" as an amnesty. It will send a very clear message to potential illegal aliens that we don't really support our immigration laws and that if they come here and stay long enough they'll eventually get citizenship.

Note that even Arlen Specter and the New York Times have admitted that "reform" is amnesty.

Opponents of "reform" should try to avoid getting into a debate about semantics. For instance, if someone rants about amnesty, a "reform" supporter would latch onto that and simply replay their talking points about "reform" not being amnesty. Instead, opponents should make the point above; most people will agree with the point above and will disagree with someone who tries to pretend that most outside the U.S. won't perceive it as amnesty.

However, the best choice is probably to just avoid the word "amnesty" altogether. Instead, use their word - "reform" - and then show how that "reform" won't work; see the comprehensive immigration reform page for some of the downsides.

There is, however, one group of people for whom any type of comprehensive immigration reform is amnesty: business owners that have knowingly hired illegal aliens. Their workers will be legalized, and - unlike those workers - they won't face any fines. Any type of comprehensive immigration reform will give them a complete pass for their past illegal activity.

But, unless using "amnesty" to make that point, avoid the term. For instance, if you ask a politician this question:

"Why does McDonald's want amnesty so much? Are they in the habit of doing things that increase their wage costs, yes or no?"

They'll latch on to "amnesty" and you'll get a reply like this:

"No one wants amnesty, I don't support amnesty. Under my comprehensive immigration reform plan, undocumented workers will pay a fine and learn English. You see, Lazarus fallacy... immigration tradition fallacy... nation of immigrants.. jobs Americans wont do..."

If you rephrase that question as follows (with the quotes around "reform" expressed or implied), they'll at least have one less thing they can use to avoid answering the question:

"Why does McDonald's want immigration "reform" so much? Are they in the habit of doing things that increase their wage costs, yes or no?"

Politicians are trained or accustomed to using various tricks to avoid answering questions. Don't give them something they can latch on to.

Last modified Jan 5, 2014
Discussed in (click each link for the full post):

Amnesty supporters Bruce Braley and Joni Ernst battle over definition of "amnesty" - 09/29/14

... have followed the advice on the reform not amnesty page: don't call amnesty "amnesty" when dealing with amnesty supporters, because they'll do exactly what Braley did above: start arguing about terms. Instead, Ernst should have used the term comprehensive immigration reform, and then showed how that would harm the U.S. If Ernst weren't very pro-big business, she would be able to undercut Braley...

Jeb Bush and Clint Bolick mislead, promote bad immigration policy - 01/25/13

... that most Americans give it (see reform not amnesty). What they seem to be getting at is described at amnesty require: a deceptive way to sell amnesty to its opponents. Any form of legalization would send a completely wrong message, not just to illegal aliens but to the elites in business, the media, and other groups. See questions 4, 5, and 6 here. The last sentence above promotes the anti-...

Elizabeth Emken on immigration: weak, GOP boilerplate (amnesty, California, Feinstein) - 09/10/12

... she's playing word games, see reform not amnesty. 5. What about "[t]hose that are here illegally must go through the proper legal immigration system"? Doesn't that mean she opposes what most people call "amnesty"? Not necessarily: she could be thinking of some form of "touchback". Rather than copying and pasting, just do a find for "symbolic gesture" here. Or, she could just mean she'd put...

Paul Ryan is bad on immigration, find out how much (Mitt Romney VP pick) - 08/11/12

... he's playing word games; see reform not amnesty. * Whatever he wants to call it, Ryan clearly supports some form of legalization for millions of current illegal aliens. He'd just make them make a symbolic gesture first: "New legislation addressing immigration policies should require illegal immigrants seeking a green card or citizenship to leave the United States and reapply for citizenship...

Haley Barbour lobbied for Mexican government, now misleads about amnesty - 02/15/11

... program. See #4. 2. He's using the reform not amnesty canard. His "reform" would be perceived by millions of potential illegal aliens as amnesty, no matter what he wants to call it. See that link for the details. 3. He's using the deportations false choice canard, pretending that we must choose between mass deportations and legalization when there are other options, including attrition. 4. The...

John Morton of ICE misleads, says he and Obama don't support amnesty - 08/12/10

Back in 2007, former Department of Homeland Security secretary Michael Chertoff said that the DHS wasn't "in the business of doing amnesty". Now, the head of the DHS' Immigrations and Custom Enforcement ("ICE") is making similarly false claims.

Could Obama declare an immigration amnesty by executive order? - 07/30/10

[See the updates too] Back in Feb. 2009 we offered Could Obama and Napolitano enact a mini-amnesty... without Congress? about a scheme cooked up by two immigration lawyers under which the president could in effect give amnesty to large numbers of illegal aliens. Now, some inside the USCIS are proposing their own workarounds and loopholes under which Barack Obama could give thousands (or more) of...

Meg Whitman highlights how much she agrees with Jerry Brown, still misleads about immigration - 07/16/10

... words games as discussed on the reform not amnesty page. She also supports massive immigration: If the next great inventor lives in India, China or Mexico today, we should welcome that inventor coming to America legally to create jobs and prosperity here. Why exactly? Why should we braindrain the world? Isn't it - in the long run - better for us not to braindrain the world? What if, in order to...

Amy Chance of SacBee misleads about "amnesty" (Steve Poizner's anti-Meg Whitman ad) - 04/10/10

... just playing word games; see the reform not amnesty for a longer discussion. "Fact-checkers" like Amy Chance should tell you that rather than enabling Whitman's attempt to deceive. [1] sacbee.com/2010/04/10/2668481/adwatch-poizner-launches-misleading.html [2] megwhitman.com/platform_topic.php?type=immigration&page=1

Amnesty supporter Meg Whitman misleads about immigration - 03/30/10

... support isn't amnesty; see the reform not amnesty page for a longer discussion. Too often, the rhetoric surrounding this issue has been overly divisive and disrespectful to Latino American citizens. The country needs to have a thoughtful debate about how we stop the tide of illegal immigration that strains budgets and angers taxpayers. But the immigration debate must take place in a measured way...

Mexican consul: "We're not demanding amnesty but immigration reform." (travel boycott) - 03/21/09

A group of illegal immigration opponents including the California Coalition for Immigration Reform are passing out fliers encouraging tourists to visit the U.S. southwest instead of Mexico (link). More on the boycott below, but first: [Orange County, CA] Mexican Consul Carlos Rodríguez y Quezada disputes the fliers' claims that Mexico urges amnesty, is violent and is a bad neighbor. "We've always...

Bill Richardson misleads on immigration (again, and again...) - 07/28/07

Not content to simply lie about the border fence or to be a shill for the OAS, on June 12, 2007 Bill Richardson made two misleading statements about immigration: 1. He offered the now-standard "false choice" between a massive legalization plan (i.e., amnesty) and mass deportations. He forgot to mention a third choice: "attrition". Under that plan we'd enforce our current laws in order to...

Bush has forgotten the Alamo - 03/06/04

The Alamo was stormed 168 years ago today. That's a long long time, and George W Bush has obviously forgotten all about it: A text of President Bush's joint news conference with Mexican President Vicente Fox on Saturday... BUSH: Hola, que tal? Bienvenidos. Mr. President, Laura and I are pleased to welcome you and Marta to Crawford... I will work to ensure a system of safe and orderly migration....