Take action now: Take the Stop Amnesty Challenge.

It's up to you to block Obama's amnesty.
 

Questions for politicians and political leaders

Many of today's political problems could be solved if people would get off their couches, grab their video cameras, and go ask politicians tough questions to their face at their public appearances. Those tough questions would point out flaws in the policies those politicians espouse, call them on their lies, and generally hold them accountable. Their answers to those questions can then be uploaded to video sharing sites so thousands, hundreds of thousands, or millions of people can see them.

If politicians knew that regular citizens would expose their lies and call them on their flawed policies to their face on video, fewer of them would lie and fewer of them would offer flawed policies. Please note that I'm discussing questions, not just rants. I'm also not suggesting asking questions about relatively minor personal matters, hypocrisy, and so on. Note also that I'm referring to "prosecutorial-style" questions, which is quite a bit different from what's to be found on cable TV.

Please note: what many people think of as tough questions are in fact not tough at all. Almost all of the questions (and probably every one) that were asked at townhalls in the summer of 2009 were not in any way tough: they were simply requests for information, or rants, or open-ended questions that politicians were able to deflect with ease. Most questions for politicians you'll find online are like that. The questions I'm talking about are designed to make stock replies, deflections, etc. difficult; they're designed to discredit the person being asked by revealing flaws in their arguments, the fact that they can't think things though, the fact that they're lying about important issues, and so on. Please see this page for a more detailed discussion.

Don't count on the mainstream media to ask those type of questions: they've rarely shown an interest in actually pressing politicians on issues, and almost all of them have no knowledge of specialized topics.

Regular citizens have to ask these questions. And, if for some reason you can't do it, then at the very least you can urge others to get involved.

Some possible questions are among the posts listed below. A couple examples of what not to do are here. Some examples of questions that were asked are here. And, if you want to come up with your own questions, here are some tips.

And, here's the outlines of an action plan:

1. Find a few friends and start a local group. Your focus can be on one or more local politicians or on any national politicians who come to your area.
2. Find others to join the group; use Facebook, Craigslist, local newspaper and other forums, etc.
3. Compile a list of future public events that politicians will be attending in your area.
4. Recruit one or more people to ask questions; if you can find a trial lawyer or similar that would be great.
5. Find some questions; feel free to use the ones in the posts below or use the guide linked above. I'm also willing to edit questions for maximum effectiveness.
6. Get a video camera, a Youtube account, and Windows MovieMaker.
7. Go to the event and ask the question.
8. If you get a good response, upload it to Youtube and promote it via blogs, forums, Digg, Reddit, etc.

Last modified Jan 26, 2010
Related Twitter conversations:
Discussed in (click each link for the full post):

Ask this Ebola question, earn $100 - 10/20/14

I'll give $100 (make that $170, see below) to the first person who uploads a video of them asking a national Democratic Party politician this question (subject to the rules below): "If we'd had travel restrictions with West Africa, wouldn't it be much less likely that two American nurses would have been infected with Ebola inside the U.S.?" The rules are very simple: 1. You have to ask this at...

The Stop Amnesty Challenge - 10/08/14

It's vitally important to stop Obama's amnesty-by-executive-order now. If we don't stop it now, Obama could legalize millions of illegal aliens and rolling that back is going to be very difficult. Thankfully, there's a way to stop Obama's amnesty right now. To make that happen, I'm announcing the Stop Amnesty Challenge. The winner and runner-up of the Challenge will win cash awards, but more...

Question about the DREAM Act - 10/08/14

This question is part of the Stop Amnesty Challenge. See that page for the details on the Challenge. This is an advanced question that will require you getting into a brief debate with the politician. It may also involve you questioning their loyalty to their fellow citizens. If you're willing and able to do that, please use this question. The question is for any politician that supports a...

Question about subsidizing American farmworkers - 10/08/14

This question is part of the Stop Amnesty Challenge. See that page for the details on the Challenge. This question is only for Republicans that support some type of comprehensive immigration reform or guest workers or mass legalization. That's most national GOP leaders, including those who say they don't support amnesty. Here's the question: Earlier this year, Rush Limbaugh floated the idea of...

Question about immigration reform being an amnesty for employers - 10/07/14

This question is part of the Stop Amnesty Challenge. See that page for the details on the Challenge. This question is appropriate only for politicians who support the 2013 Senate immigration bill (the "Gang of Eight" bill). That's true of most national Democratic Party leaders, but make sure and double check before asking. This question is designed in part to show wrong a stock trick politicians...

Question about Obama's executive order on immigration - 10/07/14

This question is part of the Stop Amnesty Challenge. See that page for the details on the Challenge. This question is appropriate for Democratic Party leaders in Congress and the Obama administration, especially those who've clashed with WalMart in one way or another. See the immigration wage floor page for background. Here's the question [1]: My question is about Obama's executive order on...

Question about Ebola and skilled immigration - 10/06/14

This question is part of the Stop Amnesty Challenge. See that page for the details on the Challenge. This is the basic question: I'd like to ask you about immigration to the U.S. by skilled professionals, something you support. Liberia is one of the countries hit hardest by Ebola. Earlier this year, there were only around 200 doctors in all of Liberia. Under the policies you support, any number...

Stop Obama's Executive Order: Ask Tough Questions at August 2014 Townhalls (list of meetings) - 08/05/14

... Questions The posts listed on the Question Authority have dozens of questions you can use. In particular, here are dozens of questions I asked White House officials earlier this year. Here are 40 questions oriented towards Republicans, and a few more and still more. For supporters of the DREAM Act (which includes most Democratic leaders), see that link. Here are questions oriented towards those...

40 Questions Neel Kashkari Refuses to Answer - 06/21/14

... public appearances using the Question Authority plan and upload his answer to video sharing sites: college slots are finite; every slot that goes to an illegal alien was taken from a citizen. Will you oppose DREAMAct? you want to legalize millions of illegal aliens. Will that give more power to the far-left, yes or no? will the mass legalization of illegal aliens you want give even more power...

Questions for Michelle Obama about immigration - 06/18/14

... during Q&A sessions. See the Question Authority page for an action plan. Obviously, the establishment media can't be counted on to ask her questions designed to put her on the spot, so that means you are going to need to help out. You can also use these questions to discredit some reporters [2]. 1. At the ceremony, you used the trite talking point "nation of immigrants". Since someone can't...

Immigration questions for Neel Kashkari (California, governor) - 05/15/14

Former George W Bush administration official Neel Kashkari and clownish Tea Parties type Tim Donnelly are vying to be the Republican who'll lose to Jerry Brown in the California governor race. Kashkari and Donnelly debated on today's John and Ken show on KFI, and let's just say it wasn't exactly Firing Line. In fact, it was no better than an establishment media debate. While I've heard host John...

Questions for Dara Lind of Vox Media (immigration "cards") - 04/07/14

Vox Media is a new, corporate-sponsored [1] venture from Ezra Klein, Matt Yglesias, and others (see those links). One of their not-so-innovations is "cards": a series of blurbs about one topic divided into several pages. It will help their Slate-style target audience pretend they aren't reading a listicle. One such "card" is from Dara Lind, where she makes some questionable statements about...

Tough questions for the White House "Big Block of Cheese Day" - 01/25/14

... accountable. See the questions in the Question Authority for some tough questions I'll be tweeting on that day using the #AsktheWH hashtag. A selected set of questions will be included below over time. ADDED: I wrote a program to create and send these tweets alone and to various administration officials, around 450 tweets total. To obtain the list in a text file, contact me @24AheadDotCom_ ....

Skype's Ask The Whitehouse scam (Biden, Munoz, immigration, Bing, Microsoft) - 12/10/13

[IMPORTANT UPDATES BELOW] There have been several scams or near-scams where internet services solicit questions for politicians which are then asked on those services. Several years ago, Youtube joined with CNN to solicit video questions that they asked at a presidential debate; they chose the weakest and dumbest questions possible. See popular voting systems for several other examples. But, the...

10 immigration questions for Mark Zuckerberg (Facebook, FWD.us) - 11/24/13

... to ask the questions. See the Question Authority page for more. 2. Encourage reporters to do their jobs and ask the questions. Contact @WrightUps, @greenbergerj, @erlenorton, @benjaminbell and others associated with ABC and ask them when they'll have those questions asked. If they don't respond, look up those they chat with and point out that they aren't doing their (idealized) jobs. 3. Tweet...

Charlie Rose's very weak immigration interview with Jose Antonio Vargas - 09/29/13

... Rose will never ask anyone, see Question Authority. Want to do something about this? Tweet the following people associated with CBS This Morning and ask why Charlie Rose didn't ask any of the questions above: @ChrisLicht @Kdprince @Jennasakwa @Mosheh @PaigeKK @mollykord @RyanKadro @mooseNYC @megawalsh @ErinELyall @KiraTV @katywithawhy @emh021 Alternatively, be a better journalist than Charlie...

Ask Reince Priebus these questions about the RNC immigration amnesty resolution - 08/17/13

... encouraged to do that also. See Question Authority for a basic action plan and questions for other leaders. See bad questions for many examples showing that simply ranting at politicians doesn't work. The first set of questions is based on this part of the resolution: Whereas, in an age of global terrorism, drug cartels, human trafficking, and criminal gangs, the presence of millions of...

Ask Reince Priebus this very basic immigration question he doesn't realize he raised (RNC chairman) - 06/28/13

This site has covered politicians saying some dumb things, and the following quote from RNC chairman Reince Priebus ranks right up there (link): "We need comprehensive immigration reform. I don't think we can continue to drift along with this mess of immigration laws that we have. And a mess that in many regards has been the results of our government not even enforcing the laws that are in place...

Questions for Kelly Ayotte about comprehensive immigration reform (amnesty, New Hampshire) - 06/09/13

... everyone to try to ask her (see question authority for the most effective way to ask these questions): Question 1. In your OpEd, you use several talking points including obscure phrases that several other people have used. You or your staff didn't originate those phrases, so the question becomes who wrote part or all of your article for you? Your OpEd uses these talking points (see each link for...

Questions for the United Methodist Church on immigration (UMC, GBCS) - 02/08/13

The United Methodist Church (through their General Board) supports comprehensive immigration reform (aka amnesty). Here are some questions about that position keyed to umc-gbcs.org/issues/immigration At that page, they write: The story of the United States is the story of immigration. The history of the United States is characterized by waves of ethnic groups arriving to these shores searching...

Questions about immigration reform for Reihan Salam - 01/24/13

Reihan Salam of National Review discusses Marco Rubio's amnesty and comprehensive immigration reform in general here and here. Here are some questions based on those posts. The reader is urged to ask Salam these questions in comments, on Twitter (@reihan), and at his personal appearances: 1. You say "[Marco Rubio's] approach reflects core conservatives priorities". Here are 10 reasons Marco Rubio...

Questions about the "high" cost of immigration enforcement - 01/07/13

The Migration Policy Institute has released a study claiming that the cost of immigration enforcement is too high. Here are some questions for those leaders who are using the study to push their loose immigration/amnesty agendas. They should be able to answer these questions, yet the chance of any of them doing so is small. Since they won't and can't answer these questions convincingly, please re...

Mike Steele of Us Weekly: ask Obama these questions - 10/16/12

Dear Mike Steele, Editor-in-Chief of Us Weekly: I see that you're soliciting questions from your readers that you'll ask of Barack Obama in an upcoming interview (link). I have four questions that I urge you to ask. Most people are expecting you to ask incredibly weak questions about things that don't matter. Here's your chance to not only prove them wrong, but to break news and to do a great...

Ask The Atlantic evades a tough immigration question (Garance Franke-Ruta, amnesty) - 09/14/12

... of the question below. See the Question Authority page for more information on the process, and see the recent posts on the DREAM Act page for more information on Obama's amnesty. Note that most of those harmed by Obama's amnesty will be Democrats. A text version of the chat is below, together with screen grabs. "GFR" means Garance Franke Ruta. Also below are a few statements I made in response...

GOP consultants: which Hispanic outreach approach is better? - 08/30/12

... know that too. You can use the Question Authority technique if you're able to contact consultants where they'll be speaking. I'll be contacting some in those fields myself and I'll update this post with their replies (or their failure to reply). ----------- [1] The Approach I favor and other aspects can be easily guessed, but I've tried to keep the above free from my own editorializing. [2]...

Questions for fiscal conservatives (and Teaparty and libertarians) - 08/09/12

... ideology and ask them. See the Question Authority page for an action plan. Video of a fiscal conservative really being pressed on one or more of these questions - after it's uploaded to sites like Youtube - could help show hundreds of thousands or millions of people the flaws in their ideology. You can also ask these questions via Twitter, on blogs, and through other means: just record and...

Challenge: get Ted Cruz to oppose Comprehensive Immigration Reform and describe his legalization and guest worker stance - 07/27/12

As detailed here and here, Senate contender from Texas Ted Cruz keeps repeating the same basic speech on immigration and doesn't disclose whether he would support some form of Comprehensive Immigration Reform or other legalization. I'm challenging anyone to find Cruz discussing those issues, or to ask him about it. Note that some politicians play word games on immigration: someone who'd dishonest...

Jesse Ferguson of DCCC: why can't Democrats debate? (trackers stalking politicians) - 07/18/12

... Idiocracy, go take a look at the question authority plan. Instead of lying in wait in bushes, the Democrats can find smart, experienced questioners to go ask politicians tough questions on video. Note that I'm referring to experienced questioners, not interns. And, I mean tough, reputable, logical questions: not smears. See how to ask tough questions and see examples of bad questions people have...

Questions for skilled immigration supporters - 07/16/12

... their failure to respond. * See Question Authority for a general action plan. * See how and why to discredit intermediaries. * See skilled immigration for background on the topic. If you don't get involved, things are going to continue as they have: those like Michael Bloomberg are going to keep promoting bad policies, and the media is going to keep just writing them down. Here are the questions...

Questions for Michel Martin: Tell Me More about your illegal immigration propaganda - 12/10/11

... failings. That involves using the Question Authority plan to really press NPR representatives on their immigration coverage. For instance, go to one of Michel Martin's public appearances and ask her one or more of these questions: 1. Approximately how many Mexican immigrants (legal or illegal) go on to become brain surgeons? It's got to be a very small number, doesn't it? If we let in the large...

AskObama on Twitter, July 6, 2011: how to make it effective - 06/30/11

[UPDATE: Things went exactly as expected, AskObama on Twitter was a sham.] On July 6, 2011, Barack Obama will be answering questions sent to him via Twitter [1]. All past instances where Obama has been asked questions have been almost completely worthless shams that haven't held him accountable. This page presents a plan that - if I can get enough help - will finally hold him accountable and...

My brief Twitter chat with Gary Johnson on immigration - 04/25/11

The graphic below shows the questions I posed to Gary Johnson on Twitter today when he conducted a live chat. Obviously, accusing him of not replying wasn't a smart move, but my Twittering setup isn't ideal [1]. On the other hand, when he did reply it wasn't exactly to my questions and he didn't respond to my follow-ups. It was just an hour and lots of other people were asking him questions, so...

Immigration questions for Gary Johnson - 04/25/11

... video sharing sites; see the question authority plan. Obviously, Johnson stands no chance whatsoever of becoming president of the U.S. However, the goal here isn't to discredit him so much as discredit his massive immigration stance, using him as simply a proxy for all other supporters of massive immigration. Because he stands little chance at the presidency he's going to be making a large...

Another Youtube/Obama scam: ask State of the Union questions - 01/26/11

[UPDATE: Make sure and see this too] Youtube and Barack Obama are conducting yet another scam, soliciting questions for Obama based on the State of the Union that he'll answer on Thursday, January 27. Other users vote up or down submitted questions, and then Obama will answer the top vote-getters. The questions that get the most votes will invariably not be the best questions, the ones that Obama...

Immigration questions for Sean Bielat - 10/25/10

Sean Bielat is the tea parties favorite who's challenging Barney Frank for Congress from Massachusetts. His immigration position follows [1], followed by some questions for him. In the following, each number in parens indicates a question below. I'll invite him via Twitter [2] to answer these questions, and the reader is invited to do the same: @SeanBielat. I believe in an America that protects...

Ask Harry Reid about his strong immigration bill from 1993 - 08/13/10

... video sharing sites; see the question authority page for an action plan. For instance, you can ask Reid a question like the following: "Sen. Reid, your 1993 immigration bill - something you later apologized for - sought to, among many other things, reduce alien smuggling. If you'd pursued that bill instead of withdrawing it, wouldn't there be fewer alien smuggling cases than there have been?" I...

"Demand Question Time": another bipartisan sham (petition, demandquestiontime.com) - 02/03/10

... outside the Beltway to follow the question authority plan and use smart, adversarial questions to "cross-examine" political leaders and attempt to discredit them by showing how they've lied, misled, or failed to think their policies through. You aren't going to get anything like that from the "Question Time" events. Note that I've been promoting the question authority plan for just about three...

Ask Jonah Goldberg: do you support childish mocking of Obama, or Buckley-style questioning? - 01/28/10

... engaging in debate, such as with our question authority plan. Ask him to renounce sleazy, childish tactics and instead attempt to raise the level of debate in the U.S. You can email him at JonahNRO *at* gmail.com or send him a tweet at @JonahNRO. Please contact your friends via social networking sites and ask them to do the same. As a further sign at how childish the reader's letter is, Glenn...

How to get Eliot Spitzer's questions for the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission asked - 01/13/10

Disgraced former New York governor Eliot Spitzer offers "10 Questions The Financial Crisis Commission Must Ask" (link). Some are pretty good, others would only generate a stock response. However, simply posting questions on the internet is meaningless if there's no way to get them asked. While the Huffington Post certainly has some influence, if you want those questions to be asked you need to...

Example: how to make a question for a politician better (Obama healthcare) - 12/10/09

The page mentioned in the previous post (toptenhealthcarequestions.com) contains this question for Barack Obama: The Administration has repeatedly claimed that its health care reform plan will not cover illegal aliens. The Congressional Research Service recently issued a report contradicting the Administration's position, stating "H.R. 3200 does not contain any restrictions on non-citizens...