Take action now:

Today's immigration is not the same as yesteryear's

Many claim that because the massive immigration that occurred a century or so ago worked out OK, the current massive immigration will similarly work out OK.

This argument is an instance of the logical fallacy "Appeal to Tradition". The context has changed from a century ago. While there are certainly parallels, there are many differences and it's quite a leap to claim that the current situation will work out the same.

In fact, here are just nine of the differences between then and now:

  1. Many of today's immigrants are from Mexico, and the U.S. Southwest was briefly Mexican territory. Most past sending countries never held territory inside the U.S. The belief that the Southwest was stolen from Mexico is widespread in that country; in fact, a Zogby poll conducted in Mexico had 58% saying that the U.S. Southwest rightfully belongs to Mexico. There's also an indigenous movement holding that anyone of "native" blood should be able to travel anywhere within the Americas at will. There's no elite opposition to those sentiments, and in some cases the elite supports those sentiments.
  2. Many of our current illegal aliens are from a neighboring country, meaning they don't have to make a clean break, they can go back and forth. There are families with members on both sides of the border as well as a few million mixed-status families inside the U.S. (i.e., families with some legal/citizen members and others as illegal aliens).
  3. Related to that, past immigrants came here on ships; current immigrants can and do walk over.
  4. There wasn't a far-left, Gramscian "multiculturalism" movement a century ago. The related issue of political correctness makes it difficult for some to, for instance, use the correct names for things ("illegal aliens") rather than euphemisms ("undocumented workers").
  5. There were ethnic newspapers, but nothing like today's ethnic media.
  6. Immigrants who came through Ellis Island were checked for disease and suitability. And, they were pre-screened by the cruiseship companies, who were charged if someone was rejected. Nowadays, anyone can overstay their visa or just walk across.
  7. There's been a rapid increase in dual citizenship, leading to U.S. citizens with divided loyalties. 14% of U.S. citizens are eligible to be dual citizens, and Mexico encourages dual citizenship as a way of obtaining political power inside the U.S.
  8. The welfare state hardly existed a century ago.
  9. Obvious to anyone who's been to, say, Dallas or Los Angeles, there were many fewer people here a century ago than there are now.

Note that Univision anchor Jorge Ramos agrees with me on at least part of the above. In 2008, he said ( peekURL.com/z8xwFdB ):

The Hispanic community has created its own cultural space within the United States. That's different than for any other group of immigrants in the past. ... It's easier for someone in New York or Chicago to talk to the family via the Internet or a cell phone, or simply to go back and forth to Mexico or El Salvador, than it was for an Italian immigrant to go from New York to Sicily.

Last modified Jul 12, 2011
Discussed in (click each link for the full post):

Scott Walker supports mass immigration, probably including amnesty - 11/20/13

... immigration is like yesteryear's is the immigration tradition fallacy, see the link. 3. Walker is using the system is broken canard. 4. The idea that more legal immigration would dry up illegal immigration is absurd. There's a huge supply of potential illegal aliens, and loosening our immigration laws even more would send a message to them that they should try to come here one way or another....

Jason Stverak misleads about immigration and the free market (Franklin Center, Koch, Krieble) - 10/04/13

... begins with a variant of the immigration tradition fallacy. He writes: One hundred years removed from its peak, Ellis Island continues to represent all that America has done to open its arms to immigrants. Unlike today's broken immigration system, the focus was on hard work, and we allowed the market, rather than the federal government, to determine how many immigrants passed into America each...

Michael Barone's shallow, 2470-word logical fallacy ("A Nation Built for Immigrants", WSJ) - 09/22/13

... fundamentals have changed. See the immigration tradition fallacy page for a more detailed discussion of the fallacy Barone engages in. Barone barely even acknowledges the points made at that link. The closest he comes is this: The elites of 100 years ago responded with aggressive programs of, in Theodore Roosevelt's word, Americanization. Public schools taught American values and made sure that...

Questions for Kelly Ayotte about comprehensive immigration reform (amnesty, New Hampshire) - 06/09/13

... us (who must be deported).") * immigration tradition fallacy ("As a nation of immigrants, we must remember that we're all descended from people who came here from somewhere else in search of a better life. In generations past, immigration has enriched our nation culturally and economically. We are all heirs to the dreams and hard work of the immigrants who helped build this country -...

Crazy Rand Paul fully supports amnesty, misleading, Hispandering, and reading poetry to do it - 03/19/13

... generations of immigrants did. See immigration tradition fallacy for why that might not necessarily be true. Defense of the unborn and defense of traditional marriage are Republican issues that should resonate with Latinos but have been obscured by the misperception that Republicans are hostile to immigrants... See the MacDonald note above. ...Republicans who criticize the use of two languages...

Questions for the United Methodist Church on immigration (UMC, GBCS) - 02/08/13

... needed change today. 1. That's the immigration tradition fallacy. Would the United Methodist Church ("UMC") care to post a bond guaranteeing that current immigration will work out the same as past immigration? 2. That's also the unlimited membership fallacy: the fallacious idea that joining a club requires one to support anyone else joining the club. UMC continues with three suggestions: Learn...

Matt Yglesias' crazy libertarian immigration plan would harm hundreds of millions of people - 10/05/12

... Yglesias also engages in the immigration tradition fallacy, see that link for the details. Please take a moment and write @MattYglesias with your thoughts. Even better, search for those he converses with and tweet them this post (use the short link below).

George Will, Michelle Rhee, Mel Martinez, Jose Vargas all hype anti-American DREAM Act and mass immigration (Christiane Amanpour) - 07/03/11

... busts (rather than promoting) the immigration tradition fallacy. 9. Rhee says "we cannot, I think, make kids suffer for decisions that were made by people other than them. We have to focus on what's right for those kids." Where exactly is her concern for the American kids who'd be harmed by the DREAM Act, a policy she supports? What would she say to one of her fellow citizens who wouldn't be...

Obama misleads about immigration yet again (May 10, 2011 El Paso version) - 05/10/11

... broken, immigration wage floor, immigration tradition fallacy, and secure the border. How many more can you spot? A (360kb) screengrab of my Twitter feed where I pointed out in real time additional ways he was misleading or promoting bad policies is here. If anyone believed anything Obama said in his speech, leave a comment on this post and I'll try to change your mind. ADDED: Another bogus...

Obama thinks illegal aliens are Americans; forgets about massive unemployment; promotes massive immigration - 09/29/10

... our immigrant traditions"; see immigration tradition fallacy. He then states, "yes, let's secure our borders"; see secure the border. Making a false claim about policy, he thinks if we made legal immigration easier we'd reduce illegal immigration. He ignores the fact that there are about 6.5 billion people outside the U.S. (and about 5 billion of them are poorer than Mexicans). And, a large...

Harry Reid's skin tone fallacy; can't see how Hispanics could be Republicans - 08/11/10

... immigration is different; see the immigration tradition fallacy page. UPDATE: From politico.com/news/stories/0810/40948.html Angle's campaign seized on the comment, telling POLITICO in an e-mail that “Harry Reid cannot give any good reasons why people should vote for him, so now he is turning to race and ethnicity.” “Reid is desperate to change the subject from the economy, which he knows is a...

Jeb Bush, Robert Putnam mislead about immigration and assimilation - 07/03/10

... private conversation. Now, see immigration tradition fallacy for what they're engaging in. Drawing lessons from the past has to be done carefully because the situations between then and now are different. For instance, it would be exceedingly difficult for Iowa to outlaw speaking Spanish in public nowadays. Bush and Putnam fail to note that one possible reason why German-speakers are confined to...

Obama immigration speech, July 1, 2010 - 07/01/10

... fallacy he's engaging in, see immigration tradition fallacy. To begin with, our borders have been porous for decades. Obviously, the problem is greatest along our Southern border, but it’s not restricted to that part of the country. In fact, because we don’t do a very good job of tracking who comes in and out of the country as visitors, large numbers avoid immigration laws simply by...

Doris Meissner misleads, downplays border security's role in terrorism, uses bogus talking points - 05/02/10

Doris Meissner - former INS commissioner and now working for the Migration Policy Institute - takes to the pages of the Washington Post to offer "5 Myths about immigration" (link). The title is unintentionally correct: most of them have her spreading myths to varying degrees. The five are listed below in bold, followed by my comments:

Illinois Business Immigration Coalition: Republican gov. Jim Edgar joins with Mexico-linked ICIRR - 04/09/10

... deportations false choice and immigration tradition fallacy and the posts in immigration economics for why that's wrong, and note also that Edgar seems to be parroting a highly-flawed study from the far-left Center for American Progress for his claim about the costs of mass deportations (not that anyone in a position of power is suggesting that of course; see the first link in this paragraph)....

Andrew Rosenthal of NYT co-opts St. Patrick's Day to support massive and illegal immigration - 03/17/10

Andrew Rosenthal - editorial page editor of the New York Times - has no concept of shame, willing to bend any and all subjects to his favorite: supporting massive and illegal immigration. Just the latest instance comes in "San Patricio" (nytimes.com/2010/03/17/opinion/17wed4.html):

Newsweek "Most Overblown Fears" of decade include immigration and globalization (Ilan Stavans, Tom Friedman) - 11/22/09

... year. 5. For the rest, see the immigration tradition fallacy page. The other "overblown" fear - globalization - is discussed by Thomas Friedman of the New York Times (2010.newsweek.com/top-10/most-overblown-fears/globalization.html). Showing how he's wrong is left as an exercise.

Obama at Hispanic Prayer Breakfast: same old immigration speech (+sounds like McCain) - 06/19/09

Earlier today, Barack Obama spoke at the Esperanza National Hispanic Prayer Breakfast [1]. Others in attendance included Cecilia Munoz, Ed Rendell, and Janet Napolitano; the event was organized by Rev. Luis Cortes of Esperanza USA. Obama simply reiterated his commitment to comprehensive immigration reform as he's done several times before, and he uttered the same old canards about that amnesty...

Michael Dukakis mindlessly spouts massive immigration talking points (Michael Bendetson) - 05/24/09

... spot: * immigration debate tone * immigration tradition fallacy * strawman: the debate isn't really about immigration as a concept it's one of levels and the like; "anti-immigration" is not the correct term * enforce the laws, but... * the system is broken * false choice offered between mass deportations (over whatever time frame) and amnesty, thus a failure to acknowledge attrition * failure to...

Mike Kingsbury /SEIU offers bad economics, bad logic (legalization as a "wage floor") - 05/04/09

... last part engages in the stock immigration tradition fallacy. 2. The first part engages in a new talking point noted recently here which will be called the immigration wage floor fallacy. 3. He continues with the immigration vulnerable fallacy. 4. His use of "citizens" is open to interpretation. Perhaps he realizes that many or most of those marching are not citizens and that most citizens aren'...

NCLR conducting "National Call-In for Immigration Reform" April 27 to May 1 - 04/23/09

... suspected, Henderson engages in the immigration tradition fallacy and disreputably compares the Civil Rights Movement to giving illegal alien Hispanics rights to which they aren't entitled.

Nancy Pelosi: immigration enforcement separating families is "un-American" (Luis Gutierrez, Kelly Zito) - 03/08/09

... swipe at WASPs and engages in the immigration tradition fallacy on this video. Note that back in October 2003, Pelosi traveled to Mexico and accused her own government of conducting "terrorizing" immigration raids. If you want to learn about immigration-related matters before Fox News gets around to them, subscribe to our feed.

NYT: illegal immigration is "New York's special gift to America" (unhinged anti-Gillibrand editorial) - 01/31/09

The part Mexican-owned New York Times offers the editorial "Listening to Ms. Gillibrand" (link). They're wrong as usual, and they're even more unhinged than usual too. Red-faced with anger at country mouse Kirsten Gillibrand's Upstate ways, they lose it right about here: Ms. Gillibrand's House votes on immigration amounted to a repudiation of New York's special gift to America. She allied herself...

John McCain promotes illegal alien amnesty to Irish group; Irish government link; no Barletta - 09/22/08

Speaking at the Irish-American Presidential Forum earlier today in Scranton PA, John McCain promoted giving an amnesty to not just the supposed 50,000 Irish illegal aliens in the U.S., but others as well. The video is below, and per this he said: "[There are] 50,000 Irish men and women in this country illegally who want to become citizens... we have to give them a path to citizenship... [My...

Melinda Zosh lets Jason Riley/WSJ engage in logical fallacy, Michael Barone spout nonsense - 06/23/08

... you missed it above, see the immigration tradition fallacy page for a detailed description of that canard.

The childlike Dave Weigel - 08/22/06

David Weigel of Reason is guest posting at Andrew Sullivan's blog and offers a discussion of Pat Buchanan's latest book that's even dumber than that that Sully would have provided. Can anyone point me to the border towns where democracy has collapsed, supplanted by Latin American-style caudillos? We can come close: "Mexican drug cartels take over U.S. cities", colonias, "Task force targets...