"Welcome the stranger" (i.e., illegal aliens)
Summary (posts follow):
One of the religious justifications offered by those who support illegal immigration is their contention that the bible contains multiple exhortations to "welcome the stranger". Religious leaders transmogrify that into a command to support people moving to the U.S. at will. For the religion-based answer, see this and this. There isn't a non-religion based answer that I know of, but those who make this argument can be discredited in other ways based on simple morality. See the false compassion discussion.
Last modified Feb 8, 2009
Discussed in (click each link for the full post):
Obama misleads about immigration yet again (May 10, 2011 El Paso version) - 05/10/11
... citizens.
ADDED2: Obama also used the welcome the stranger canard. I ask again: is there a talking point he did *not* use?
6/.9/11 UPDATE: Perhaps not surprisingly and perhaps not unjustifiably, Obama's "moat" comment got the most attention, despite the fact that practically every other word in the speech was misleading. So, here's the part where Obama mentioned the moat:
"We have gone above and...
"Tour of the Faithful": Catholic Church, others try to change immigration laws (America's Voice) - 09/13/08
In September and October, the Catholic Church and others will be holding interfaith events [1] across the U.S. designed to support "comprehensive immigration reform", aka amnesty. This "Tour of the Faithful" (catholicsinalliance.org/node/20123) was apparently organized with the help of Frank Sharry's America's Voice [2] and includes an appearance by former president Jimmy Carter and many others [...
You can't trust what Harold Meyerson says (immigration edition) - 12/19/07
Harold Meyerson of the American Prospect offers a vile, illegal immigration-supporting smear piece called "Hard-liners for Jesus". Pretty much everything in it is bad, including comparing the GOP to the KKK. And, he misleads about the immigration stance of all the GOP candidates and the vast majority of GOP voters:
But it's on their policies concerning immigrants where Republicans -- candidates...
Lawrence Downes/New York Times misleads & smears, and all to support illegal activity - 12/10/07
[Update here]
Lawrence Downes offers an "Editorial Observer" article in the New York Times entitled "Showdown in Arizona, Where Mariachis and Minutemen Collide". It describes a running protest by illegal immigration supporters in front of the M. D. Pruitt furniture store in Phoenix. He had the temerity to try to keep day laborers off his property, employing off-duty sherriffs in the process. And...
Sojourners/Jim Wallis promoting massive amnesty to Congress - 04/07/07
Continuing the age old debate about whether someone is a crook or an idiot, Jim Wallis' Sojourners organization is sending out an email to their mailing list urging people to contact Congress in support of a massive illegal alien amnesty. A purported copy is here: tgdarkly.com/blog/?p=542
Wallis has a blog at beliefnet.com/blogs/godspolitics, and I urge everyone to leave comments there...
U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops supports Senate amnesty (Part #44849) - 09/26/06
From this:
Religious leaders Tuesday scolded lawmakers who oppose a broad immigration policy overhaul and urged them at a Capitol Hill news conference to put people over politics.
As pointed out here many times, their policies will make the situation far worse. A much better suggestion is that they think things through and put what's in the best interests of all concerned ahead of their own...
- Want more coverage? Sponsor posts here
- Help hold politicians accountable: promote the plan to intellectually engage politicians by asking them tough questions on video. Take a few minutes right now and promote that plan.
- Tired of CNN's bogus debates? Help promote policy debates, with experts - not newscasters - quizzing politicians about the downsides and side-effects of their policies.
- Actually, there is a debate about skilled immigration.
- Vote up this plan to get immigration enforcement considered as a way to reduce unemployment.
- How to stop amnesty and minimize illegal immigration
- To reduce illegal immigration, discredit intermediaries
- How to ask politicians tough questions
- Get anti-"Birthers" to take this test
- Join the TiredOfTeaParty page on Facebook
- Follow FWD US (Forward US) is wrong
- Topics - easy-to-use categorized listing of our 9,000+ posts since 2002
- Top topics
- How and why the Teaparty movement should be opposed.
Random topics:
- 04/16/2007: Laugh: Cynthia Tucker wins Pulitzer Prize for Commentary
- 05/11/2005: Irony on the Border, Part 5: Mexico clamps down on immigrants
- 05/16/2007: Possible Senate amnesty deal, Part 2 (Z Visas, Captain Ed)
- 12/16/2004: "Exclusive: UN Conference Shuts Up Reporter; Calls Global Warming Science Questions 'Silly'"
- 01/11/2005: Wikipedia Watch: You'd think she was Mother Teresa
- 02/05/2007: Travel NYT style: sneaking into the U.S. is jolly fun
- 02/15/2007: Freeway offramp fruit sellers: products from supermarket dumpsters?
- 10/19/2007: E.J. Dionne, Chris Cillizza/WaPo realize: voters oppose illegal immigration (Niki Tsongas)
- 10/11/2005: Oklahoman brings kids to Brooklyn to experience "diversity"; kids beaten, called "cracker"
- 10/03/2006: "[USCIS] Whistle-blower let go"
- Illegal immigration: an introduction
- See the top posts in the last 45 days.
- Monthly archives
- Here are five things you can do about the Obama administration's lawsuit over Arizona's immigration law.
- Need a correction? Spot an error? Post about it here
- See the Assignment Desk.
