immigration vulnerable

Illegal aliens are powerless, most vulnerable people in society

Many supporters of illegal immigration make the claim that illegal aliens are the most vulnerable people in our society and that they're powerless.

That claim is self-evidently ludicrous. While the claim might be true in some ways of individual illegal aliens, the claim is false of *all illegal aliens as a class*. Almost the entire establishment rushes to defend illegal aliens as a class, and when almost the entire establishment has your back you aren't vulnerable.

Those very powerful defenders who rush to defend illegal aliens as a class are those who want to profit from them in some way:

* Democratic politicians who want their numerical power now and their votes in the future...

* Business interests who employ them...

* Banking interests who want to profit from remittances, giving them home loans, or holding their deposit accounts...

* Republican politicians who are in effect paid off by those business and banking interests (many Democrats are, of course, also in effect paid off)...

* Far-left organizations who receive millions from wealthy donors (such as the Ford Foundation and many others) and who file endless lawsuits against immigration enforcement, conduct advocacy campaigns, and so on. Those organizations include the American Civil Liberties Union and hundreds more...

* Racial power groups who, of course, want more race-based power: the National Council of La Raza, MALDEF, and hundreds more...

* Many religious leaders who see illegal aliens as potential converts...

* Almost the entire media...

The list could go on. The bottom line is that - as a class - illegal aliens are a very protected class and by the top echelons of the U.S. (the establishment).

In fact, those who make the claim that illegal aliens are the most vulnerable people in our society are usually those who have a great deal of power. Defenseless, vulnerable people don't have such powerful defenders.

Compare that with the case of American citizens who are negatively impacted by illegal immigration. They do have power, but they don't have anywhere near as much power as that of the establishment. When Americans speak out against illegal immigration, they're frequently smeared by the establishment using the race card. Or, the media and politicians will simply ignore their wishes.

Last modified Oct 24, 2011
Discussed in (click each link for the full post):

Jim Wallis has a low opinion of his supporters (Sojourners, immigration reform) - 02/19/14

If you're a follower of Jim Wallis of Sojourners, I have some bad news: he has a very low opinion of you. In a post at Time Magazine [1], he writes false and misleading statements that would make a used car salesman blush. And, apparently he thinks his supporters aren't going to pick up on how he's misleading them.

Is Michael Brune delusional, or does he think you are? (Sierra Club executive director, immigration) - 06/03/13

In the Darren Samuelsohn article previously discussed, Michael Brune - the executive director of the Sierra Club is quoted as saying this about illegal aliens:

Peter Beinart smears GOP, sticks up for illegal immigration - 10/24/11

Peter Beinart of the Daily Beast and the CFR offers "Why the GOP Demonizes 'Illegals'" (link) in which he smears the GOP

Soledad O'Brien "Latinos in America" not biased enough for NILP (+ she lies) - 11/09/09

The National Institute for Latino Policy (latinopolicy.org) raised issues with the recent "Latino in America" documentary by Soledad OBrien of CNN, and O'Brien responds to their concerns here. While I didn't watch it, I didn't have to: it was almost assuredly a complete puff piece. However, it wasn't enough of a puff piece for some: ...So many in our community told us we could not do a story about Latinos without showing how our controversial immigration debate is tearing apart families and encouraging some folks to target the most vulnerable among us (note: see immigration vulnerable)....

Gutierrez unveils immigration "reform" bill principles at Washington DC rally (RI4A, CHC,NCIC,religious leaders) - 10/13/09

Earlier today, supporters of comprehensive immigration reform held a rally in Washington DC. Rep. Luis Gutierrez (Chair of the Congressional Hispanic Caucus Immigration Task Force) laid out outlines of a bill he'll supposedly be introducing later this year. The specifics aren't known but it will be very lax and probably won't include the "symbolic gestures" from the bill he co-authored with Jeff Flake. Others attending were Nydia Velazquez (Chair of the Congressional Hispanic Caucus) and Mike Honda (Chair of the Congressional Asian Pacific American Caucus). Per Ian Urbina of the New York...

Rep. Luis Gutierrez wants illegal aliens in healthcare exchange; emulate Blue Dogs for amnesty - 09/15/09

Rep. Luis Gutierrez - a buffoonish fervent supporter of illegal immigration - recently spoke out in favor of allowing illegal aliens into the Obama healthcare "exchange".

Mike Kingsbury /SEIU offers bad economics, bad logic (legalization as a "wage floor") - 05/04/09

Mike Kingsbury of the Service Employees International Union offers the exclamation point-rich blog post "What a week for immigration reform!" (seiu.org/2009/05/what-a-week-for-immigration-reform.php). He's so excited he forgot to think things through, saying this about the recent immigration marches: Why we as citizens don't do this more often, I don't know. I do know that putting a floor under the most vulnerable workers in this country will help maintain a standard of living for all of us. And this year's May Day theme emphasizing America's immigrant history - immigrant roots, immigrant...