New York Times offers hazy thoughts on immigration

The NYT offers the editorial "Hazy Days of Immigration". As you might expect, it's wrong. Just as an example, let's take a look at the final paragraph:

Mayor Michael Bloomberg of New York City said it well, at a Senate hearing: "It's as if we expect border control agents to do what a century of communism could not: defeat the natural market forces of supply and demand and defeat the natural human desire for freedom and opportunity. You might as well sit on your beach chair and tell the tide not to come in."

Mayor Mike's blather sounds reasonable, until you actually think about it. Which is clearly something that the NYT did not do (or thinks their readers won't do).

The current situation is not like the ocean. It's like sitting on a beach chair at Raging Waters watching the tide being forced in by giant underwater paddles, while at the same time staring at the $10 ticket stub in your hand.

The current situation is not an example of "natural market forces". It's an example of corporatism: companies that engage in illegal activity - wittingly or no - get cheap labor, and stick everyone else with the bill.

It doesn't matter whether the NYT can't figure this out, or thinks their readers won't figure it out. In either case, no one should trust their opinions on this matter.

Comments

Bloomberg does not understand between legal and illegal immigration. Both can be controlled only that illegal can do further worst that those who are coming here legally. Penalize both employer of illegal immigrants and the illegal workers and there will be no lump sum deportation. Illegal immigrants will self-deport because there is nothing anymore that attracts them here. This process is better that building a billion dollar fence.

well it looks that this shit bloomberg is under the control of mexico and bin laden and as far as natural forces go its my idea to show some of the rats what that really means! the idea of the tide sounds to me like a old communism line back in the 1950's about the new man! and defeat is what this government and its little rats are all about.